Most of the buses are actually marshrutkas - that is, minivans. These
minivans are, for the most part, Ford Transit kind (and quite beat up at
that). There are some Mercedeses, which are in much better condition,
safer and also faster. As if to defy Russia, you won't find here any
GAZelles, which are pretty much the only marshrutkas in Armenia or
southern Russia. If I compare it with other countries where minivan
transportation is usual, in Thailand most of minivans are Toyotas, with
sizable proportion of Mercedes and some Fords or Mitsubishis, generally
in much better condition. In poorer Indonesia, though, a lot of minivans
are the tiny Daihatsu or Suzuki kind, in condition that is even worse.
But let's get back to Georgia. Marshrutkas are fairly safe. If we
disregard lack of safety belts, generally cramped condition (sometimes
unbelievably packed) and non-existent emergency exit, the drivers, for
the most part, drive carefully and not too fast (a Ford marshrutka
anyway hardly hits 100 kph - 60 mph with its tiny engine).
But the maintenance is much worse. Most marshrutkas are actually
second-hand vehicles from Western European countries, like Germany or
The Netherlands. The owners/drivers do not bother to change/repair
whatever needs to be done, and the tyres are the worst part. I have
personally experienced a puncture (because the tyre was so badly worn) -
luckily, it was a Mercedes with double back wheels. I have also seen a
big piece of tyre chipped off, so that it had no rubber layer anymore
and could blow anytime. The driver was avare of this and said it was Ok,
although the marshrutka plied the very demanding Svaneti route (Zugdidi
to Mestia). And then I was honored to ride a marshrutka which tyre was
constantly rubbing against its body. Not to mention the
countless minivans that have no tyre tread anymore (and no-one cares). I
guess the only time the tyres are exchanged on a Georgian marshrutka is
when they blow up.
Then there are buses - not too many, but they are second-hand Western
buses, mostly from Greece. That's understandable, because Greece is
close and has the best fleet of buses in Europe (equalled only by Turkey
in the world and surpassed by Malaysia and Iran). They're pretty old
Mercedeses, Setras or Neoplans (some of them even from 70s and 80s!),
but reliable and fairly comfortable. They are not very fast either
(especially considering the bad state of Georgian roads) and priced
about the same as marshrutkas.
Safety of buses seems to be better than marshrutkas, as they don't seem
to be in disrepair and their sheer size protects passengers should a
traffic accident happen. But not all buses are comfortable western ones.
Local buses are mostly Ukraininan 'Bogdan's with Isuzu engines, and
while most of them are respectable, there are some which are
unbelievably old and terribly beat up.
I personally take one such bus weekly. It has this nice sign - 'Pri avarii steklo rozbit molotkom', which translates from Russian as: In case of accident break the glass with the (supplied) hammer. Of course the hammer is long gone, but that's not the point. The point is that if there is accident, the whole bus will very likely crumble into a heap of scrap metal and there will be nothing to break, whether you have a hammer or not.
Smoking doesn't seem to be permitted on marshrutkas and buses, but drivers and people sitting in the front seats routinely chain-smoke. Sometimes even passengers light up a cigarette, but then you have to be persistent and tell them there is to be strictly no smoking or else you'll call the police (only then people realize that they shouldn't smoke on a marshrutka).